Philadelphia residents are struggling to provide their families with nutritious food and the economy is not solely to blame.
While Philadelphia is the sixth largest city in the nation, it has the second lowest number of supermarkets per capita.
According to The Food Trust, a non-profit organization based in Philadelphia, low-income, minority adults and children struggle to maintain a healthy diet due to limited access to healthy food in their neighborhoods.
The Food Trust is dedicated to insuring all residents have access to affordable and nutritious food through several of their programs including the Pennsylvania Fresh Financing Initiative (FFFI), the Supermarket Campaign, the Corner Store Initiative and the Farmer’s Market Program.
The lack of supermarkets in the Philadelphia area is due in part to the growth of the suburbs and in part to retail disinvestment from urban communities.
Many supermarkets left the cities to follow the population growth in the suburbs. Supermarket developers are unsure that building in low-income areas is a profitable business investment.
“I don’t think it’s a conscious decision and in no way an evil decision. I think it’s just a business decision,” said April White, communications coordinator for the Food Trust.
“For example, is there a well trained workforce in the neighborhood that they can work with? In under served, low income areas, they tend to believe the answer is no. We have found that is not really the case,” she said.
Prior to her role as communications coordinator, White was the food editor at Philadelphia magazine for eight years. She also co-authored a cookbook with famed chef and restaurateur, Jose Garces.
The Food Trust’s FFFI serves the financing needs of supermarket operators that plan to operate in under served communities. Frequently, traditional financial institutions and banks will not provide the loans and credit necessary to proceed with this type of project.
“That is one of the most important points of the initiative … this gap financing allows supermarket developers to look at this as a great business decision in addition to being helpful in other ways to the community,” White said.
One of the under served areas is in North Philadelphia, usually defined by locals as north of Girard Avenue. This is also the home of Temple University.
Drexel University and the University of Pennsylvania have had major impacts on the landscape of University City and West Philadelphia. In the last five years, three new apartment complexes opened and the restaurant scene continues to expand featuring a new Mexican restaurant by Jose Garces.
In University City, there are two grocery stores within three blocks of one another; the Fresh Grocer on 40th and Walnut Street and a Thriftway on 43rd and Walnut Street.
Despite the purchasing power of thousands of Temple University students, the same development has not occurred in North Philadelphia.
“When Amy Guttman came in at Penn, she had a very clear vision for expanding Penn beyond its boundaries. They made a really big push to embrace that neighborhood … you see less of that from Temple,” White said.
But Temple University students and North Philadelphia residents have been promised a grocery store is coming to their neighborhood. A Fresh Grocer, to be located in the historic shopping center, Progress Plaza. This project has been postponed on numerous occasions, often for years at a time. The most recent completion date, January, 2009 was missed and is now expected to open in January, 2010.
Progress Plaza was the first black owned and developed shopping center in the nation. It initially opened in 1968.
Progress Plaza is located on North Broad Street between Jefferson and Oxford Streets. This community has been without a grocery store since the Super Fresh, also located in Progress Plaza, closed 10 years ago.
“Progress on Progress Plaza’s development has been halted and delayed so often, the jokes playing on the center’s name stopped being funny a while ago,” said the Editorial Board of Temple-News Online.
The Temple Student Government is combating these delays by providing a shuttle service for students that will run from the main campus to a shopping center in South Philadelphia that contains retailers like Super Fresh and Target.
While North Philadelphians continue to anticipate a grocery store in Progress Plaza, the Food Trust stresses that grocery stores and large supermarkets are not the only remedy to the problem of access to healthy food.
“The size of the access that you put in is not necessarily important,” said White.
As a part of the Food Trust’s Corner Store Initiative, they have succeeded in providing residents with fresh, healthy options in the community’s corner stores.
“We put in fresh fruit salads and helped with marketing. We also introduced a brand of water; both financially competitive with other things you can buy in the store,” she said.
This initiative educates students in the classroom and also works with corner stores that surround the schools. The plan is that students will buy healthier items when they come and go to class. The fruit salad is $1.00 and the water is 75 cents.
“The classic, enormous, supermarket model is very difficult [to implement] in the city … but that’s not the only solution,” she said.
The Food Trust also operates 29 farmer’s markets in the Philadelphia region. Some of the most popular are the Clark Park and Headhouse farmer’s markets.
“We accept access cards and food stamps at all of our farmer’s markets. We also do a lot with outreach to inform people about their options with food stamps,” White said.
Some Philadelphians argue that new supermarkets and grocery stores will not solve the deep seeded issues of low-income, under served communities.
“The problems of lower income (urban and rural) neighborhoods are very complex. Food is a basic essential, and children who are healthy and well nourished have better opportunities,” she said.
White also noted that increased access to healthy food can curb epidemics like childhood obesity which can manifest into diabetes and other dangerous, expensive health issues.
Supermarkets act as economic engines. They employ people within in the community and often serve as the anchor store for the development of other stores. White points out that an area that has higher employment, typically has less crime.
White explained: “It’s not going to solve every problem, but it’s a positive on a lot of fronts.”